Understanding Boundary-Spanning in Knowledge Work: Implications for IT Use*
نویسنده
چکیده
interests include understanding collaboration practices on multi-party systems development projects, knowledge management in IT service delivery organizations, IT outsourcing strategy and implementation, and technology design principles in heterogeneous environments. Her research interests concern the construction of intra-organizational boundaries with practices of IS and the transformation of the relationships between CoPs and formal organization with agents' use of ITs. She has presented her work at the Academy of Management Conference and has published ABSTRACT Knowledge work requires the spanning of inter-and intra-organizational boundaries to integrate diverse competencies and foster innovation. Information Technology (IT) is often viewed as a critical tool for boundary-spanning. Yet many experiences with IT implementations for spanning boundaries have been disappointing. We explore this issue by asking: How is IT used to span the boundaries in knowledge work? The organizational literature has distinguished two boundary-spanning devices: boundary spanners and objects. Currently, the main perspective concentrates on boundary spanners' roles and on boundary objects' properties and considers boundaries as fixed. We propose a complementary perspective on boundary-spanning that focuses on boundaries themselves. Bourdieu's practice theory helps us conceptualize the dynamics of boundaries and boundary-spanning practices. Following Bourdieu's principles for conducting empirical work, which emphasize comparative methods, we apply this conceptualization to two in-depth case studies. We find that only boundary spanners-in-practice (as opposed to boundary spanners-in-role) actually span the boundaries in knowledge work. Moreover, only boundary spanners-in-practice create and use boundary objects-in-use. We also note that, in the presence of boundary spanners-in-practice, IT-based artifacts can be used as boundary objects. As IT-based artifacts become boundary objects-in-use, their structural properties change. Furthermore, agents who use IT-based artifacts to span the boundaries in knowledge work become spanners-in-practice, leading to the emergence of a new boundary-between spanners and non-spanners. We draw implications of these results for IS and management research and practice.
منابع مشابه
Boundary spanning in the context of academic education
Despite the emergence of the concept of boundary spanning in the fields of behavioral psychology and organization theories, this concept is still somewhat unknown in the health and medical education system. Meanwhile, one of the approaches and activities that can help to improve the health and medical education system is boundary spanning activities. Thus, boundary spanning is considered as a v...
متن کاملThe Embedded Health Management Academic: A Boundary Spanning Role for Enabling Knowledge Translation; Comment on “CIHR Health System Impact Fellows: Reflections on ‘Driving Change’ Within the Health System”
Healthcare organisations are looking at strategies and activities to improve patient outcomes, beyond clinical interventions. Increasingly, health organisations are investing significant resources in leadership, management and team work training to optimise professional collaboration, shared decision-making and, by extension, high quality services. Embedded clinical aca...
متن کاملBoundary-Spanning in NIOC’s research projects: Literature meta-synthesis and the direction of future research
The complex and ambiguous nature of innovative activities has forced organizations to think beyond their conventional boundaries. In this regard, inter-organizational projects are carried out with the aim of developing complex technological systems, changing organizational routines and developing capabilities. Designing and implementing inter-organizational projects creates many inter-organizat...
متن کاملSpanning the Boundary: Measuring the Realized and Lifecycle Impact of Distinct Boundary Spanning Activities on Project Success and Completion
For work teams to be effective, maintaining communication ties with other individuals and teams elsewhere in the organization—an activity typically referred to as team boundary spanning—is necessary for obtaining resources critical to project success. Within the literature on boundary spanning, the positive relationship between a team’s boundaryspanning activities and their performance has been...
متن کاملThe Dynamics of Sensemaking, Knowledge, and Expertise in Collaborative, Boundary-Spanning Design
This study investigated how a project group deals with the contradiction between distributed knowledge in boundary-spanning collaborative processes and the expectation that software systems will provide unified, codified knowledge. It employed an ethnographic, interpretive approach to examine the ways in which relevant knowledge was presented, recognized, shared or otherwise managed during a pr...
متن کامل